Meet the classic mayo masterpiece. Made the traditional way with whole egg, and batch-churned with the moxie of a one-wheeled moped doing donuts on your tongue.
Craft the perfect potato salad, build the most bombastic burger, or make your steak sing. We’ve also been told that this mayonnaise is the perfect coating for a classic cheese toasty!
SideCar is your ultimate taste-bud buddy, here to make mealtimes memorable again.
153 reviews for SideCar Original MayonnaiseWrite a review
Show allMost HelpfulHighest RatingLowest Rating
★★★★★
Jo Wallace–
Great Flavour, and very creamy, Kids love the flavour and I we have just about finished the sample 🙂
+ PROS: PROS - Packaging easy to open, Flavour is creamy delicious
we have eaten this product almost everyday
- CONS:CONS - The Jar is large - i am concerned we will not consume the Entire jar before need to replenish
Helpful(0)Unhelpful(0)You have already voted this
★★★★★
Mary Brennan–
Best mayo I’ve ever tasted! I have already purchased more. I’m going to stick with this mayo from now on!
+ PROS: So good. Love the fact in comes in a glass jar. Comes in 4 flavours. I give this 5 out of 5.
- CONS:I would like to be able to purchase a bigger jar.
Helpful(0)Unhelpful(0)You have already voted this
★★★★★
Maureen–
My new mayo fave, Sidecar is like a tastier more natural Best Buys.
+ PROS: Creamy, tastes awesome. Love the reusable, recyclable jar.
- CONS:Bit pricey but oh well.
Helpful(0)Unhelpful(0)You have already voted this
★★★★★
Shin Chan–
Disappointing Quality and Limited Use –
I had high hopes for Sidecar Mayonnaise after hearing some buzz, but unfortunately, it didn’t live up to expectations. Here’s a breakdown of my experience:
Overall, Sidecar Mayonnaise feels like a missed opportunity. While the texture might be on point initially, the lack of flavor and quality control makes it fall short. I wouldn’t recommend this if you’re looking for a reliable, flavorful mayonnaise.
+ PROS: Consistent Viscosity (When Intact): Before the separation issue, the texture seemed promising — smooth and creamy.
Decent for Sliders: When paired with stronger, savory flavors, it works well enough to go unnoticed.
- CONS:Separation Issues: The jar I received had split, with oil sitting on top. Stirring helped somewhat, but it never fully came together.
Bland Flavor: For a product meant to be versatile, the taste is far too mild and lacks that tangy richness you want from a good mayo.
Limited Use: It's not suitable for salads or sandwiches where the mayo needs to shine on its own — it only works as a filler for sliders or burgers.
Helpful(1)Unhelpful(1)You have already voted this
★★★★★
peneloe mcgettigan–
I absolutely loved this product. For me, it blows Best Foods right out of the water. Flavour and texture is top shelf and its made in New Zealand.
+ PROS: Flavour texture and taste
Helpful(3)Unhelpful(0)You have already voted this
★★★★★
Ed S–
Interesting! Not sure could replace Best Foods though
Helpful(1)Unhelpful(0)You have already voted this
★★★★★
Ollie–
Excellent Mayo! It is just a plain Mayo but fantastic taste and quality. Was perfect in a potato salad
Helpful(0)Unhelpful(0)You have already voted this
★★★★★
Maria Kroonenberg–
Creamy, tasty, versatile – we loved it!
+ PROS: Taste, texture, packaging (we love the jar over squeezy bottles)
Jo Wallace –
Great Flavour, and very creamy, Kids love the flavour and I we have just about finished the sample 🙂
Mary Brennan –
Best mayo I’ve ever tasted! I have already purchased more. I’m going to stick with this mayo from now on!
Maureen –
My new mayo fave, Sidecar is like a tastier more natural Best Buys.
Shin Chan –
Disappointing Quality and Limited Use –
I had high hopes for Sidecar Mayonnaise after hearing some buzz, but unfortunately, it didn’t live up to expectations. Here’s a breakdown of my experience:
Overall, Sidecar Mayonnaise feels like a missed opportunity. While the texture might be on point initially, the lack of flavor and quality control makes it fall short. I wouldn’t recommend this if you’re looking for a reliable, flavorful mayonnaise.
peneloe mcgettigan –
I absolutely loved this product. For me, it blows Best Foods right out of the water. Flavour and texture is top shelf and its made in New Zealand.
Ed S –
Interesting! Not sure could replace Best Foods though
Ollie –
Excellent Mayo! It is just a plain Mayo but fantastic taste and quality. Was perfect in a potato salad
Maria Kroonenberg –
Creamy, tasty, versatile – we loved it!
boneyemz –
This mayo is delicious, creamy, tasty and yummy with all sorts of foods.