Who ate all the pies? Proper Steak & Cheese Pie
$18.99
The Iconic Kiwi pie, taken to the next level. We use the finest Southland sirloin, diced by hand, seared and cooked low and slow in our very own rich beef stock. A generous helping of tasty cheese finishes off this tasty local favourite
117 reviews for Who ate all the pies? Proper Steak & Cheese Pie
Show all
Most Helpful
Highest Rating
Lowest Rating
Roxanne Hepi –
Delicious.
Debbie –
Mixed reviews on this pie. The steak was good quality and there was enough in the pie. The gravy was gelatinous. we didn’t enjoy the texture.
Janet –
Enjoyed this pie as it a very tasty with good quality meat.
Andy Dunbar –
Very tasty pie with nice lean meat, no gristle and great gravy. Pastry was a little soft but didn’t overwhelm the pie which happens with several other brands. Would eat it again.
Ali M –
Mixed review here…nice pastry …very tasty gravy…problem is where was the meat? Two miniscule pieces in the whole pie..seemed like a Gravy and Cheese pie. Therefore little texture. I see other reviews stating large chunks of meat…maybe I just got unlucky.
Catherine –
Really good flavour, the gravy was delicious and huge pieces of steak
Edna –
This pie was delicious and had some nice big chunks of meat. Nice crisp pastry. Great flavour. My daughter said Mummy likes this because the meat melts in the mouth.
G Tilley –
Not my favourite pie.
Joss Prince –
Good size, chunky meat, crisp pastry. I followed the instructions for heating in oven, however I think the 18 minutes was too long and took out after 16 minutes. I’m not a sauce person so found the filling didn’t have enough gravy.
Michael S Holmes –
Great Pie!!…Good size, full of good chunky pieces of Meat, plentiful and tasty cheese, nice exterior pastry, bloody great meal.
Ada –
Very yummy and convenient to have in the fridge for evening snacks
Brian –
Pie was very nice. Usually store bought pies are not the greatest, but this is an exception. Tender and tasty.